55810239. sy475

*This is not the official SPFBO book review. I read it for my own enjoyment*

4/5 stars


Blurb: The war is over, but something is rotten in the state of Eidyn.

With a ragged peace in place, demons burn farmlands, violent Reivers roam the wilds and plague has spread beyond the Black Meadows. The country is on its knees.

In a society that fears and shuns him, Aranok is the first magically-skilled draoidh to be named King’s Envoy.

Now, charged with restoring an exiled foreign queen to her throne, he leads a group of strangers across the ravaged country. But at every step, a new mystery complicates their mission.

As bodies drop around them, new threats emerge and lies are revealed, can Aranok bring his companions together and uncover the conspiracy that threatens the kingdom?

Strap in for this twisted fantasy road trip from award-winning author Justin Lee Anderson.


I had high hopes from the outset after hearing good things about this book. Part of me wished this had been a new find, though, since rarely does a book meet expectations when you all you hear is how fantastic it is and that you should read it. Not that I was disappointed, mind you, for The Lost War is certainly a good book. It just didn't blow me away like I'd hoped. 

We are introduced to Aranok, the main character, as he rescues a lad named Vastin from men sent by the king to claim taxes on Vastin's forge. He is accompanied by his bodyguard, Allandria, and together they loop Vastin into a quest from the King, Janeus. Janeus and Aranok are best friends, and Aranok is also the King's Envoy. Along with that, Aranok is also a draoidh, a type of magician who can control earth elements. As the story progresses, it's clear that most of the commonfolk fear draoidhs, but realize that in a lot of ways they are dependent on them. Aranok grew up privileged, as well as a magician, yet he comes across as humble, brave, and generally likeable. He has his flaws, including an impulsive streak that gets him into trouble at times. But I truly liked this character. I also liked the other characters in what becomes a troupe of travelers on a quest. Allandria brings sense to Aranok's impulsivity and they balance each other well. Samily is a Thorn, a well-trained warrior monk who is asexual (she's a woman, but isn't sexually attracted to any gender, so that was unique), a nearly unstoppable fighter, and one of my favorite characters in this book. She challenges Aranok's lack of faith in God without being preachy, and it was a nice element to the plot. Then there is Glorbad, a rough around the edges type of mercenary who has a dark past he doesn't want to talk about, followed by Nirea, a sailor whose soft side often annoys her, but endears her to the reader. Meristan also joins the group, a priest who is also Samily's teacher. All together, they set off on a quest for the King to rescue (maybe? or maybe not) a Queen from the clutches of the mysterious Mynngogg.

Now, from the outset the plan doesn't go as, well, planned. The group keeps getting sidetracked from their quest by anything from scary demons in cocoons (yes, you read that right) to murder. I found myself frustrated at times, wondering how these various smaller quests fit into the whole of the plot. And not every loose end made a lot of sense at the end, either. Perhaps they will be tied up in the next installment. 

The magic system is straightforward enough, yet left me wanting more information. As mentioned before, there are draoidhs who can wield various elements, such as earth, air, fire, etc. They specialize in one area. Then, as it turns out, Samily can change time. There is little explanation for how this actually works, and the information is leaked slowly through the book as to how draoidh power works, as well. It was a bit dissatisfying, in my opinion. However, this might also make more sense in the next book.

The worldbuilding was phenomenal, and my favorite part of the book. The author lays it out bit by bit, and each setting was as intriguing as the last. Each element, from zombie-like people to Reivers, seemingly a type of nomadic warrior people, to terrifying demons kept the plot racing along with little breathing room. I absolutely was enthralled by the fight scenes, mixed with debates on faith, joined by interpersonal relationships that seemed flawless and smooth. The writing was stellar. 

All in all, I really did enjoy The Lost War and will certainly be picking up the sequel when it is available. If you are a fan of high fantasy, mixed with magic, terrifying beasts, memorable characters, and don't mind loose ends or a little mystery to the magic, pick this one up. You won't be disappointed.  

The Lost War (Eidyn: Book One) by Justin Lee Anderson - Book Review 30, Sep

How an author executes the opener to their book can leave the wretched soul all twisted up in knots. Seeking that elusive hook is oftentimes as much of a quest as the hero’s journey contained within. Refreshingly, The Lost War kicks things off by dropping an F-bomb as the first word. For me, a fellow abuser of expletives, this elicited a grumble of laughter (yes, I’m immature and cursing makes me laugh), and marvel at the courage of the author. 

 The Lost War gets things underway in a strong manner, introducing us to our main character, Aranok, as a war weary, and jaded envoy to the King, with magical abilities, marking him as a ‘Draoidh’. We are introduced to a world where individuals are born with magical powers, and such people are distrusted and abused by society. 

 The story takes on a tour of the kingdom, with a quickly assembled crew made up of veterans, a blacksmith, a priest, and a knight. The crew encounter demons, and the pseudo-zombies borne of a desperate plague sweeping the country. It is this plague, the Blackening, which serves as the main thrust of the story. The crew ultimately seek to uncover a means of halting, and curing the blackening, which propels them on a path of confrontation with the villain of the piece, the awesomely named Mynygogg. 

 The writing is clean, and tight, and the characters distinct and their dialogue alive, and believable. Yes, the general thrust of the plot is familiar, but the same can be said for many solid offerings in Fantasy - indeed, there is comfort in that, and Anderson executes it brilliantly. What really stood out for me was the way the author wove in hat tips to the Gaelic language and familiar parts of Scotland and indeed Edinburgh. Whilst to many readers, these little ‘easter eggs’ would be overlooked, for me they really made the book distinct, and stand out.

 There is a twist at the end of The Lost War that I simply did not see coming, which sets things up nicely for the second book in the series.

 On the whole, a comfortable, and enjoyable read, that explored familiar paths, but did so with considerable competence, and quality. Well worth your time to read. I’ll be keeping my eye out for the next instalment.