Novik's previous novel, Uprooted, was a 2015 favourite of mine. Novik's love for Slavic folklore shined through. For the first time had I read an author who recaptured that very special feeling of magic and wonder which I hadn't felt since those childhood nights spent listening to my grandmother tell Russian and Bulgarian fairy tales. Beyond the nostalgia lay a very atmospheric, character-driven story that is well-worth the read. If you haven't read it but would like to know more, I have a short recommendation for you!
Uprooted left me wanting more of the same, and in Spinning Silver, I got it--and so much more. A fully realized story which goes down an unexpected road, with characters you'll quickly grow fond of, a world covered in winter's magic, and to top it all off...one hell of a memorable last line!
Naomi Novik went to great lengths to work on presenting the Jewish moneylender stereotype in a different light, and did admirable work with it. Antisemitism is a major theme in this book, and it is handled very well, owed to the author's Jewish heritage and skill, both.
This novel contains six viewpoints, three major and three minor ones. All are told in the first person which isn't anywhere near as confusing as you might think. That clarity is owed to the fact that Spinning Silver starts off with one character and introduces the viewpoints of the others at very logical points in the story. More on that later.
Miryem is the very first character the novel introduces us to; she is not only its first main character but also the engine of the story. She is a Jew, the daughter of a bad moneylender and the granddaughter of a great one. Without giving away too much, Miryem becomes a moneylender herself--and an excellent one at that. While collecting her debts, Miryem meets Wanda, the lone daughter of the town drunk and unknowingly gives her an ounce of freedom by demanding her father's debt be paid with Wanda's services as a maid.
Wanda sees the world in a simpler way than Miryem does. The language of her PoV sections is simpler, less colourful, as you'd expect from the daughter of a poor farmer. She is strong, though, possessing the kind of strength a young girl needs in order to survive her mother's passing at an early age. I enjoyed her development. Some serious personal growth there, making this young lady a lot more likable by the end. Some of her scenes dragged along a bit but I hardly mind.
Irina is the third main character in the book, and she's excellent. Her moral choices are delightfully gray and very clever, after a fashion. She too grows a lot -- from the sole daughter of a moderately powerful duke with neither looks nor any great talent, to a powerful woman whose choices shape her very nation, and more.
Miryem is this story's Rumplestiltskin, spinning coins of silver into gold not by employing magic, wink, but by her own wits and the occasional trickery. The road she goes down on isn't an easy one, and it's far from one her parents appreciate.
"My darling, my darling, I'm sorry."
"Sorry? To be warm instead of cold? To be rich and comfortable? To have a daughter who can turn silver into gold?"
"To see you harden yourself to ice, to make it so."
It's a very powerful road Miryem goes on early in the novel, from a kind but starving girl freezing every winter because her father can't ever force himself to take a stand against his neighbours, those who owe him money; to a young woman who takes what she is owed, threatening and cajoling and bending the truth to get what she is owed and build off it, I loved her arc most of all.
Boastful of her skill, Miryem unwittingly summons unwanted attention; the Staryk, creatures of ice and winter, thieves and hoarders of gold, pillagers and even rapists. As luck would have it, Miryem doesn't attract any old Staryk, but their king. He gives her three tasks, and a promise: To turn her heart to ice if she fails, or make her his queen if she succeeds.
See what I mean? Engine of the story.
Mild Spoilers Ahead: I absolutely loved the character of the Staryk king, both at the beginning and towards the end of his appearances; I disliked only the parts where he acted like a petulant child. The Staryk culture, their home, their inhuman nature -- I loved all those. I wonder if they are partially inspired by the Wild Hunt.
The Staryk came closer and took it from me. He didn’t pour the purse out: it was too full for that. Instead he dipped his hand inside and lifted out a handful of gold to tumble ringing back into the bag through his fingers, until there was only one last coin held between his white-gloved fingers, shining like sunlight. He frowned at it, and me. “It’s there, all sixty,” I said. My heart had slowed, because I suppose it was that or burst. “As it must be,” he said. “For fail me, and to ice you shall go, though my hand and crown you shall win if you succeed.” He said it as if he meant it, and also angrily, although he had set the terms himself: I felt he would almost have preferred to freeze me than get his gold.
SPOILERS: The Miryem/Staryk story felt like a bit of a rehash of the Agnieszka/Dragon romance from Uprooted without packing the punch that relationship had due to a lot more 'screen-time,' if you will. I enjoyed it but it was the one thing in the novel that was familiar, expected and safe to bet on.
Speaking of descriptions, this book does them really well. All of them. I didn't feel like any of them slowed down the story.
Spinning Silver transported me into its magical world; I read it for five hours straight only to fall asleep, wake up and finish it after two more hours. Truly the kind of book to miss dinner AND breakfast over. My recommendation? Read it. There's so much packed inside -- references and winks to so many myths, memorable characters forced to use their wit to survive, and loads more well worth experiencing!
It's escapism, pure and simple, and magical to boot.
You'll enjoy this book if you:
- are an Ice Elf who's looking to apply for a Wild Hunt scholarship;
- are a lover of Slavic folklore;
- enjoyed Uprooted and want something that captures the same feeling, while being very different, for the most part;
- love good escapism;
- and more! Prob'ly.